letterMotor racing: letter and reply on the Maserati drivers
A correspondent signing as Bad Taste complains that Peter Greenslade unfairly belittled Maserati drivers Schell, Shelby and Bonnier and gave a 'wooden spoon' to the Buell Maseratis. Greenslade replies that he made no claim they were not as good as New Zealand drivers, that Schell's fourth place came when the leaders were nursing their cars, and that the Buell cars' brakes and preparation were inadequate.
race reportChristchurch driver wins 50-mile sports car race
Frank Cantwell of Christchurch won the 50-mile sports car race, the premier event of the morning at the Lady Wigram Trophy meeting, in his 3.8-litre Tojeiro Jaguar in 38min 15.4sec, with Ken Harris (Monza Ferrari) within 5sec for most of the race and G. Lawton third. There were sixteen starters and no retirements. A crowd near 20,000 attended by midday; the first race began over an hour late; the Trophy field was brought to the grid on time by eliminating a motor-cycle race. Ron Flockhart (BRM) was on pole, with Brabham, McLaren and Ross Jensen alongside.
Sports Car Race (50.784 miles)
| 1 | F. D. Cantwell (Christchurch) | Tojeiro Jaguar | 38min 15.4sec |
| 2 | K. D. Harris (Auckland) | Monza Ferrari | |
| 3 | G. Lawton (Whangarei) | Cooper-Climax | |
| 4 | A. N. Hyslop (Hastings) | Jaguar XK120D | |
| 5 | J. Palmer (Hamilton) | Lotus | |
Open Car Handicap (25.392 miles)
| 1 | A. Hyslop (Hastings) | D-type Jaguar | |
| 2 | Rutherford (Christchurch) | Zephyr Special | |
| 3 | B. Brown (Christchurch) | | |
| 4 | H. Lawrence (Wanganui) | Mistral | |
| 5 | D. H. Rutherford (Culverden) | Lycoming Special | |
350cc Motor-cycle Race
| 1 | N. McCutcheon (Dunedin) | A.J.S. | 13min 20.4sec |
| 3 | J. Thompson | Norton | |
| 4 | T. R. McCleary (Christchurch) | A.J.S. | |
350cc Motor-cycle (pool petrol)
| 1 | V. K. Brown (Christchurch) | B.S.A. | |
Lap times
- Ron Flockhart (BRM): qualifying
- Jack Brabham (Cooper-Climax): qualifying
- Bruce McLaren (Cooper-Climax): qualifying
- Ross Jensen (Maserati): qualifying
Facts
- Frank Cantwell won the 50-mile sports car race at the January 24, 1959 Wigram meeting in a Tojeiro Jaguar in 38min 15.4sec.
- The 1959 Lady Wigram Trophy front row was Flockhart (BRM, pole), Brabham (Cooper-Climax), McLaren (Cooper-Climax) and Ross Jensen (Maserati).
- The crowd at the January 1959 Wigram meeting approached 20,000 by midday, and the first race started over an hour late.
- Tar began to melt on the tighter corners at Wigram on the hot day of January 24, 1959, particularly at the chicane.
photoWigram: how they fared
Cartoon captioned 'Oh Dad, could I please have a loan of the car tonight?' beside the Lady Wigram Trophy results heading.
Read the OCR text
24-1-59
Motor Racing
Sir.—On what authority does Mr
Greenslade base his assertion that the
Maserati drivers. Schell, Shelby. and Bonnier are not as good as New Zealand
drivers? Surely it cannot be his own.
But if it is, then I deplore his lack of
knowledge. But reading between tae
lines I can see his dislike for tre
Maserati trio, and this unfortunately
has been allowed to show in his report
in last Saturday's Sports. Mr Greenslade praises Flockhart for bringing the
B.R.1f. into third place before it retired,
vet he fails to see any merit in Schell's
fourth. Mr Greenslade's statement that
"no one will miss anything at Wigram.
because the Maserati drivers . . . will
not be there" smacks somehow of vin
award dictiveness, and his "wooden spoon to the Buell and the "hend aks somehow
Maseratis would certainly not gain him
an award for sportsmanship.—BAD
TASTE.
--
"The correspondent apparently has
not read the article as carefully as his
letter would suggest," replies Mr Peter
Greenslade. "No assertion was made
that Scheil. Selby, and Bonnier are not
as good as New Zealand drivers. In
deed it would be ridiculous to make
such an assertion. It would also be
ridiculous to deny thatnow it
has been proved that these overseas men (and this reference was not
made specifically to the trio in question)
have to take their chance against formidable local opposition' It is undeniable
that the cars the three would have driven
at Wigram would not have been good
enough. I have nothing but admiratión
for the three drivers and particularly
Schell. But Schell drove up into fourth
when the leaders had so much in
hand that they could aford to slow down
and nurse their cars; whereas Flockhart
made his bid when the pace was on.
-Finally, the Buell connections would probably be the first to admit that they
qualified for the 'award.' There was
virtually no pre-race preparation of the
cars in Auckland and the brakes were
inadequate for the circuit. From the
information available regarding the circuit there was absolutely no reason why
the cars could not have been fitted with
brakes of greater area before the cars left
Italy."—Ed.. "Star."
24-1-59
CHRI
50-M
STCHURCH
DRIVER
ILE SPORTS
CAR
BEFORE what promised to be a won the premier event of t
Wigram Trophy meeting to-day.
Frank Cantwell, driving his i
high-class field of sixteen starters
in 38min 15.4sec.
record crowd a Ch
he morning's raci
3.8 Tojeiro Jaguar,
to win the 50-mile
Cantwell drove copy-book
race and was followed home by
the diminutive Aucklander, Ken
Harris, in a monza ferrari.
Harris, for most of the
journey, kept within 5sec of
Cantwell, but he just could
not produce the extra littie
bit of speed to head the flying green car.
In third place was the
Whangarei driver. G. Lawton, in a Cooper-Climax.
Finished Fourth
A. N. Hyslop, of Hastings, fnished fourth in his D-type
Jaguar, and l7-year-old Jim
Palmer, of Hamilton, was next
in a Lotus.
Although the pace was a
cracker there were no retirements. However, the major placegetters outclassed the remainder
of the field.
In point of fact, they had
sorted themselves out into what
proved to be the final positions
within the first few laps.
Early Lead
From the Le Mans-type start
Cantwell was easily first away,
and it soon became obvious that.
unless he made a mistake, it was
unlikely that he would
beaten.
The crowd. which must have
approached 20,000 by midday,
gave him a tremendous reception.
It had been a long morning
for them. They began pouring
in the gates long before nine
o'clock.
The first race started more
than an hour behind schedule,
so everybody had to be contenti
with watching the practising.
The heat was terrific, and it
looked as though it would be a
scorcher. However, by noon
there was a pleasant, cool breeze,
and everyone felt much happier
and much more comfortable.
The sun had its effect on some
of the tighter corners of the circuit.
The tar began to melt and
drivers had to treat some
bends, particularly the
chicane, with great respect.
, By elminating one of the
motor-cycle races, the Motorracing Club, sponsor of the 150miles Lady Wigram Trophy
classic, was able to bring the
Trophy race field on to the
starting grid at the scheduled
time, 1.45 p.m.
On the Grid
The first row of the grid saw
Ron Flockhart, of Scotland, with
the B.R.M., in the pole positon.
Outside of him was the Australian, Jack Brabham (Cooper-
Climax), and then came the
Aucklanders. Bruce McLaren
(Cooper-Climax) and Ross Jensen (Maserati).
From the practice times it
was obvious that new records
would be set in the trophy race.
Provisional results:
Open Car Handicap, of 25.392
miles-A. Hys op (Hastings),
D-type jaguar, 8min 25sec. Zephyr
Rutherford (Christchurch),
Special, 7min, 2; B. Brown (Christchurch),
H. Lawrence (Wanganui).
Mistral. 7min 10sec. 4; D. He . Ruther-
¡ford (Cuiverden), Lycoming Special,
7min 35sec, 5. Winner's race time
-19min 29.4sec.
350 c.c. Motor-cycle Race—M. Mc-
Cutcheon (Dunedin), A.J.S.. 1:
Metem Chrichured christchurch A.J.S., 2; J.
Thompson
Vorton, 3; I. R. McCleary (Ghristchurch), A.J.S., 4. Winner's time
13min 20 2-5sec.
350 c.c. Motor-cycle (pool petrol)
Race-V. K. Brown, Christchurch
(B.S.A) * Motorcycle Race - K. 250 c.c.
McCleary. Christchurch (Jawa),
2. G Willams. Christchurch (Velo). Christchurch
(Triumph), I estell, D. Winner's cime= Christchurch (B.S.A.) 4.
15min 48sec.
Sports Car Race, of 50.784 miles.-
F. D.. Cantwell (Christchurch);
Tojeiro Jaguar, 1; K. D. Harris
(Auckland), Monza Ferrari, 2: G.
: 3; A. Lawton (Whangarei), Cooper-Ciimax.:
N. Hyslop (Hastings), Jaguar
XK 120D. 4; J. Palmer. (Hamilton),
Lotus, Winner's time-38min
15.4sec.
WINS
RACE
hristehurch drive
ing at the Lad!
flew awar from a
Sports Car Race
24-1-59
WRRRRRRRARARA
WIGRAM
САя Том
RACES MHYNE
N LADY WIGRAM HOW THEY FIE
TROPHY
"OH. DAD! COULD I PLEASE HAVE
A LOAN OF THE CAR TONIGHT?"*
Summaries and tables are machine-read from the scan and may contain errors: the scan is the record.